EUA and Global Carbon Market Analysis

Analyzing the Fluctuations and Drivers in EUA and Global Carbon Markets: A Detailed Week-by-Week Breakdown

---

{Article Table of Contents}

1. Introduction

   • Overview of the European Union Emission Allowance (EUA) Market in the Second Week of 2024

2. EUA Market Dynamics

   • Weekly Average EUA Price Decline

   • Analysis of Open Interest Trends in EUA Futures at ICE Endex and EEX

3. Market Drivers

   • Impact of Germany's Emissions Reduction on EUA Prices

   • Role of EU Gas Storage Capacity in EUA Market Stability

   • Shifts in Market Speculation: Analysis of the Commitment of Traders Report

4. Price Movements: Last Week in Review

   • Daily EUA Price Trends: From Monday's Decline to Friday's Recovery

5. Analysis of Market Drivers

   • Detailed Examination of the Commitment of Traders Report

   • Germany’s Contribution to EUA Market Dynamics through Emission Reductions

   • Role of Investment Firms and Credit Institutions in the EUA Market

6. The Impact of External Factors

   • Influence of EU Gas Storage Levels on EUA Prices

   • Assessment of Geopolitical Concerns and Their Effect on the EUA Market

7. Near Term Future Outlook

   • Predictions for EUA Market Fluctuations

   • Upcoming Auctions and Potential Impact on EUA Prices

   • Geopolitical Tensions in the Middle East and Their Implications

8. Analysis of Recent Trends in Carbon Markets: CCA, RGA, and WCA Price Movements

   • Overview of Price and Volume Changes in Different Carbon Markets

9. California Carbon Allowances (CCA)

   • Price and Volume Fluctuations: A Week’s Overview

   • Economic Influences and Market Positions

10. Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGA) Allowances

    • Analysis of Mild Price Decline and Volume Surge

    • Regulatory Developments and Their Impact on the Market

11. Washington Carbon Allowances (WCA)

    - Political and Legislative Influences on WCA

    - Price Dynamics and Regulatory Adjustments

---

The second week of 2024 marked a significant shift in the European Union Emission Allowance (EUA) market, with notable decreases in their weekly average price, EUAs reached a 15-month low.

EUA Market Dynamics

The weekly average EUA price fell by 7.78%, dropping from €73.70 to €67.96. This decrease is attributed to various market drivers, including the substantial reduction in open interest for EUA futures at ICE Endex, which plunged by 29.53% from mid-December 2023 to early January 2024.

Contrarily, the European Energy Exchange (EEX) witnessed a slight increase of 0.07% in the same period. Despite the cold snap across Europe, EUAs resisted further declines, suggesting a robust EU gas storage capable of withstanding temperature drops, hence mitigating the threat of a spike in EU gas and carbon prices.

Market Drivers

• Germany's Emissions: Reports indicated that Germany's emissions in 2023 were the lowest since the 1950s. This historic low, primarily due to the phasing out of coal-fired power production, has significantly impacted the EU's energy matrix post the Russian invasion of Ukraine, exerting downward pressure on EUAs.

• EU Gas Storage: The EU's robust gas storage, at 84.27% capacity as of early January, has helped assuage concerns about the impact of cold weather on energy supply, contributing to the drop in EUA prices.

• Market Speculation: The Commitment of Traders (CoT) report revealed a stark increase in net short positions by utilities, contrasting with previous trends dominated by funds. This shift in market behavior is a key factor in the observed price movements.

Price Movements: Last Week in Review

• Monday: EUAs saw a sharp decline, with the Dec24 contract falling by 5.2% to €72.42, influenced heavily by plummeting EU gas prices.

• Tuesday: EUAs showed some resilience against downward trends, with minor fluctuations throughout the day.

• Wednesday: The EUA price broke the €70 barrier, influenced by the CoT report’s revelation of increased net short positions.

• Thursday: A significant drop to a three-week low of €66.98, primarily driven by falling gas prices.

• Friday: EUAs hit a new 15-month low of €64 before recovering slightly to settle at €65.81, marking a near 15% decline over the week.

Analysis of Market Drivers

• Commitment of Traders Report: The CoT report showcased a complex scenario. Banks amplified their long positions significantly, whereas commercial entities, including utility trading desks, markedly increased their short positions. This behavior is a primary factor behind the recent EUA price collapse.

• Germany’s Emission Reductions: The considerable reduction in emissions in Germany, largely due to reduced coal power production, has played a pivotal role in shaping the EUA market dynamics.

• Investment Firms and Credit Institutions: These entities reduced their net short positions, reflecting a changing landscape in the trading community.

The Impact of External Factors

• EU Gas Storage: The satisfactory level of EU gas storage has reduced the urgency for higher EUA prices, as the fear of a gas shortage during the winter diminishes.

• Geopolitical Concerns: Despite escalating tensions in the Middle East, particularly in the Red Sea region, EUA prices did not respond significantly. This indicates a market more influenced by internal EU factors than external geopolitical events.

Near Term Future Outlook

The EUA market is expected to experience further fluctuations in the near term:

• Auctions Resuming: The reintroduction of auctions, with over 13 million allowances, could introduce additional supply pressure, potentially leading to further price reductions.

• Middle East Tensions: Ongoing conflicts in the Red Sea could disrupt energy supply routes to Europe, adding an element of uncertainty to the market.